Breadcrumb
![]() |
Najjar was taken without a declaration of official orders for his arrest or detention from the judicial authorities | ![]() |
If security forces in the UAE arrested Najjar simply to hold on to him for a while, for example, they are not exempt from presenting a cause for arrest or from a subsequent public pronouncement.
This is despite the fact that pre-trial detention or administrative detentions are not consistent with the principles of "innocent until proven guilty" or the necessity of first being charged with an offence.
On the contrary, pre-trial detentions undermine one of the most important foundations of the rule of law, namely the right to a fair trial.
What further supports al-Najjar's case as one of enforced disappearance is that neither his family nor a diplomatic authority was notified following his arrest of the cause of his detention, where he is being held, the period of arrest or the nature of the investigations conducted by the security forces against him.
![]() |
Neither his family nor a diplomatic authority was notified following his arrest | ![]() |
Taking into consideration that Najjar is also an expatriate, living in a country where he is not a citizen, therefore making it harder to reach out to his friends or family, responsible authorities are required to exert the utmost efforts to inform the authorities of his home state about his arrest, the reason for the arrest and the nature of the action taken in his case.
Furthermore, since he can found in the possession of the UAE authorities, there is no reason to alternatively label Najjar as a "missing person."
The absence of any information, and the denial of his ability to appoint a lawyer to defend him or to seek legal advice in order to appeal to judicial bodies makes the authorities fully responsible for his forceful disappearance, in line with the central definitions set-down by the UN body in defining "enforced disappearances".
Since the period of Najjar's "disappearance" has been relatively long, there are fears that he has been exposed to torture.
![]() |
Since the period of Najjar's 'disappearance' has been relatively long, there are fears that he has since been exposed to torture. | ![]() |
As the act itself, enforced disappearance is beyond the remit of the law, and since his disappearance began in that manner, there are no guarantees that legal violations have not occurred since he was been taken in.
That the UAE is not party to the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearances, which came into force on 23 December 2010, does not make the matter of enforced disappearances in that state either legitimate or legal.
On the contrary, resorting to enforced disappearances means that the UAE has violated a person's fundamental right not to be subjected to arbitrary arrest or unlawful detention.
It also deprives the individual of seeking legal defence and access to a lawyer, deprives them of the right to a fair and equitable trail and prohibits them to any guarantees provided by law not to be subjected to torture.
The combinations of these rights are meant to form a foundation upon which the obligations of all states, including the UAE, are built in the defence of human rights.
Fadi al-Qadi is a Middle East and North Africa Human Rights Advocate, commentator and writer. Follow him on Twitter: @fqadi
Opinions expressed in this article remain those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The New Arab, its editorial board or staff.