Third election ‘all but inevitable’ for Israel as Gantz fails to form coalition

Third election ‘all but inevitable’ for Israel as Gantz fails to form coalition
Netanyahu’s challenger Benny Gantz declared he had been unable to form a coalition after 28 days of negotiations, increasing the likelihood of a third general election in early 2020.
4 min read
21 November, 2019
Benny Gantz announced he could not form a government after 28 days of negotiations [Getty]

Israel edged ever closer to a third general election in a year Wednesday, as Benny Gantz announced his Blue and White coalition - the winner of the most seats in September's national poll - was unable to form a government.

The former army general, whose party gained one more seat than Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing Likud in those elections, said he had tried everything during his 28-day negotiation period to secure a majority in Israel's 120-seat parliament.

"I raised every stone to try and form a national unity government," he said in a speech after informing President Reuven Rivlin he would be handing back the mandate.

"I ran into a wall of losers who did everything to prevent Israeli citizens from benefitting from a government under my leadership."

In-depth: Why is Israel waging war on Islamic Jihad?

Incumbent Netanyahu, who has been in power since 2009, had been the first to be handed a 28-day negotiation period by Rivlin, but was unsuccessful in the task of forming a coalition, prompting the president to give Gantz the same opportunity.

Rivlin will now hand the mandate to the Israeli parliament, which has three weeks to try and find a candidate capable of getting the backing of the majority of the country’s 120 lawmakers.

If that period passes without a breakthrough, new elections will be called for early 2020 - the third national polls within 12 months.

Polls held last April also led to stalemate in a proportional system reliant on coalition building.

Netanyahu, who is fighting corruption allegations he denies, would remain caretaker leader until the new elections.

'Door still open'

Netanyahu responded immediately after Gantz's announcement, saying he remained open to talks in the coming weeks.

"Israel needs a government of national unity and that is why in the name of the security of Israel and in the name of the will of the people, we must form this government together," he said, addressing Gantz.

Gantz also said he was not giving up on avoiding new elections.

"There remain 21 days to achieve a democratic solution. These are a fateful 21 days during which democracy in Israel will be put to its most important test," he said.

Gantz's negotiation period was due to expire at midnight Wednesday but his hopes of forming a government were in effect dashed at lunchtime when potential kingmaker Avigdor Lieberman announced he would not back him.

The former defence minister's Yisrael Beitenu party has eight seats and held the balance of power between Gantz's and Netanyahu's blocs.

Lieberman had refused to join either coalition, accusing Gantz of being reliant upon the support of Israel's Arab parties and Netanyahu of being slave to the whims of ultra-Orthodox Jewish parties.

Instead, Lieberman favoured forming a unity government between his party, Likud and Blue and White.

Both Gantz and Netanyahu said they supported the proposal -- which would entail rotating the premiership -- but disagreed on who should be prime minister first.

Talks had continued late into Tuesday but collapsed into mutual accusations of blame.

Lieberman said both Gantz and Netanyahu had put their personal interests ahead of the country's.

"If we are dragged to new elections it will be because of a lack of leadership," he said.

A 60-year-old former paratrooper, Gantz had no previous political experience when he declared himself Netanyahu's electoral rival in December.

But he has posed the most serious challenge to Netanyahu since he became premier in 2009.

Click to enlarge


New elections would be deeply unpopular with the public, but columnist Ben Caspit, writing in the Maariv daily Wednesday morning, said they were now all but inevitable.

"The path towards establishing a government in Israel has never been at a greater impasse," he wrote.

"We are going to need a miracle to avert a third election."

Netanyahu also faces a threat to his political career from the corruption allegations.

Attorney General Avichai Mandelblit is due to decide by December whether to charge him over a series of accusations he denies.

An indictment might permanently damage Netanyahu's support, whereas a reprieve could give him a new lease of life.

Follow us on Twitter and Instagram to stay connected