Algeria to vote on a constitution dismissed by protest movement

Observers see the constitution as the centrepiece of now-hospitalised President Abdelmadjid Tebboune's strategy to neutralise the Hirak movement, which staged vast demonstrations last year and forced his predecessor from office.

Despite Abdelaziz Bouteflika's fall from power, the Hirak has failed to achieve its goal of a full overhaul of Algeria's sclerotic political system, in place since independence from France in 1962.

In a key setback for the protest movement, Tebboune, widely seen as the army's preferred candidate, was elected in December 2019 despite the Hirak urging root-and-branch reform ahead of the vote.

The movement was then forced to suspend its protests in March as the coronavirus pandemic struck.

Tebboune, who took power after a poll marred by a record low turnout, has sought legitimacy by ostensibly reaching out to the Hirak.

Read also: Normalisation with Israel: The view from the Arab Maghreb countries

He has promised a new constitutional settlement he presents as meeting the movement's demands.

But the lack of radical change in the document, which strengthens the president and the army, has left many sceptical.

"The referendum will have no impact in terms of offering a political alternative or a change in how the country is governed," said Louisa Dris-Ait Hamadouche, a political science professor at the University of Algiers.

Algeria, with a population of 44 million on the doorstep of Europe, has escaped the violence and severe repression triggered by most of the 2011 Arab uprisings.

With its oil-reliant economy in crisis, young people desperate for work and the Covid-19 pandemic, the government is under pressure.

Tebboune himself was transferred from hospital in Algiers to Germany on Wednesday, officials said, days after the 74-year-old went into self-isolation following reports of suspected virus cases among his staff.

Politically, Tebboune was already "in a delicate situation", said Algeria expert Hasni Abidi, pointing to the army's resurgent political role since Bouteflika’s departure after two decades in power.

"Even if (Tebboune) is tempted to gain more legitimacy via the ballot box, he is far from having full room to manoeuvre," Abidi said.

Stronger president, army

The proposed constitutional changes refer to a string of rights and freedoms, including guaranteeing the right to form parties and unions, while even praising the Hirak in a preamble.

But Zaid al-Ali, an expert on constitutions in the Arab world, has warned that the document "lengthens the list of rights while at the same time making sure that most of those rights are devoid of meaning."

And counter to the Hirak movement's goals, the constitution would further enshrine a presidential system and bolster the army's powers.

Since taking power, Tebboune has vowed to push through a revision that would rein in his own powers.

Despite limiting the president to two five-year terms, the revised constitution would still mandate the head of state to appoint an array of key officials including the prime minister, regional governors, judges and security service chiefs.

A vaguely worded article extending the role of the military has also rung alarm bells.

"It's a genuine invitation for the army to get involved in politics, but also a poke in the eye for the Hirak, which has demanded a civilian rather than military state," said constitutional law expert Massensen Cherbi.

The document has been carefully marketed by the government, which has led a campaign to "explain" the constitutional reform and how it lays the foundations of a "new republic".

Few, if any, voices from the "No" camp have been heard in state media outlets.

The date of the vote is highly symbolic: November 1 was when Algeria's eight-year war for independence from France began.

"November 1954: Liberation. November 2020: Change," runs the slogan of the official "Yes" campaign.

If it passes, the constitutional reform will be another serious blow for the Hirak, which has faced a slew of arrests and trials in recent months.

Activists and journalists have been handed heavy prison sentences, all in a context where the coronavirus pandemic has made it very difficult to maintain pressure against the authorities.

Press watchdog Reporters Without Borders (RSF) on Thursday called on Tebboune to ensure that "real press freedom" accompanies constitutional reforms.

Algeria ranked 146 out of 180 countries in the RSF's 2020 World Press Freedom Index.

Amnesty International has welcomed the constitution's inclusion of stronger language on women's rights and economic and social rights but warned in June of a crackdown on activists. 

"The Algerian authorities' relentless campaign of mass arbitrary arrests and a crackdown on activists and protesters risk undermining the credibility of Algeria's constitutional reform process," it said.

Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram to stay connected