New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani issued a statement on Wednesday marking the third anniversary of the Hamas-led attacks on 7 October 2023, describing the killing of around 1,200 Israelis during the incursion that triggered a three-year genocidal war in Gaza as a “horrific war crime”.
However, pro-Israel groups attacked him for acknowledging Gaza's suffering in his statement.
In his first 7 October commemoration as NYC mayor since taking office earlier this year, Mamdani released a lengthy statement mourning the Israelis killed in the attacks and commemorating the 251 people taken hostage, describing the anniversary as “profoundly painful for so many New Yorkers.”
He also condemned Israel’s military campaign in Gaza, accusing the US government of complicity in Israeli war crimes.
“The suffering did not begin nor end that day,” he said, referring to the 7 October attacks.
“That suffering has intensified with every Israeli bomb dropped on ambulances waiting outside hospitals, every drone strike targeting a residential building or journalist, and every shipment of food aid turned away at a border crossing.”
“It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza in which it has killed more than 74,000 Palestinians — including more than 21,000 children.”
The statement had received more than 11 million views on X by Wednesday evening, as pro-Israel organisations accused Mamdani of "minimising" Jewish and Israeli suffering following his criticism of Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
The backlash came from supporters of Israel, including conservative US politicians and Israeli government officials.
Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations, Danny Danon, described Mamdani’s statement as “an attempt to hijack the anniversary of Oct. 7 and turn it into yet another propaganda attack against Israel.”
In the US, Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the daughter of Mike Huckabee, US President Donald Trump’s ambassador to Israel, wrote on X that Mamdani’s statement was a “disgusting rant”, comparing it to condemning the US military response following the 9/11 attacks.
Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch, president of the New York Board of Rabbis, called Mamdani’s statement “morally perverse” and “like sticking a knife into the pain of the Jewish community in New York and in America.”
Meanwhile, Jewish organisations across New York held ceremonies to commemorate those killed in the 2023 attacks, including a candlelit vigil in Union Square organised by Israelis for Peace New York.
Mamdani attended the vigil but did not speak, standing solemnly throughout the event, as the organisers also commemorated Palestinians killed in Gaza.
Nerdeen Kiswani, founder of Within Our Lifetime (WOL), told The New Arab that acknowledging Palestinian suffering on the anniversary does not diminish anyone else's suffering.
“We reject the premise that acknowledging Palestinian suffering somehow diminishes anyone else’s,” she said.
“Palestinians have endured decades of dispossession, occupation, imprisonment, and violence, long before October 7, 2023. Their lives and histories should not disappear from public discussion because the date is politically sensitive.”
Kiswani’s comments came after her organisation joined a broad coalition of pro-Palestine groups, including the Palestinian Youth Movement (PYM) and PAL-Awda, in holding a separate protest.
Activists called for greater recognition of the political demands of the pro-Palestine movement in New York, including calls for Mamdani’s administration to translate his advocacy for Palestinian rights into “meaningful policies”.
“The broader debate should not be reduced to whether Mamdani said the right words on October 7, or whether Palestinian protesters were sufficiently deferential to him. The question is whether his administration will translate its stated opposition to genocide and apartheid into meaningful policies,” Kiswani told TNA.
She continued: “These are not demands invented in response to one October 7 statement. They are issues Palestinian organizations have raised consistently, including before Mamdani took office. Our criticism is about the gap between the principles he articulated as an organizer and candidate and the decisions he is making now that he holds executive power.”
Among the demands, Kiswani said, are calls for the removal of NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, whom activists accuse of “policing and repressing Palestine protests”, as well as investigations into Israeli settlement-related business activity and calls for divestment in New York.
Mamdani last month unveiled a plan to combat antisemitism, highlighting tens of millions of dollars already allocated to prevent hate crimes in New York City amid a reported rise in antisemitic incidents.
However, some pro-Israel and Jewish organisations criticised the plan for not addressing Israel.
Other Jewish organisations and leaders have supported the distinction between antisemitism and criticism of the Israeli government, arguing that opposition to a foreign government's policies should not be conflated with hostility towards Jews as a religious or ethnic group.