Breadcrumb
Lebanon's new media law targets transparency over funding and ownership
Lebanon's media law passed, on 12 August, after more than 16 years of parliamentary deliberation, replaced the 1962 Publications Law, which predated the rise of the internet, social media, and other digital technologies.
The new law, introduced after years of calls to update outdated legislation, incorporates several reforms long sought by journalists and civil society organisations; most significantly, the introduction of rules governing media ownership and requiring transparency for media outlets' funding sources.
The law places transparency in media ownership and funding among the key requirements for regulating the sector. Articles 15, 16 and 17 provide for the establishment of a dedicated register at the National Media Authority containing details of owners and directors, as well as the names of shareholders who hold more than 5% of shares or stakes, their ownership percentages and the holders of economic rights.
The law requires the authority to publish this information and make it available to the public, allowing people to trace who owns media outlets and identify the interests associated with them.
Transparency does not stop at ownership. Article 18 requires media outlets to disclose their financial information and various sources of income, including advertising, subscriptions, sales, loans, and cash and in-kind grants, while specifying the sources of loans and grants.
Article 19 also gives the National Media Authority the power to verify the accuracy of this information, including by appointing auditors. This means the law moves media ownership and funding from the realm of information unavailable to the public into a legal framework that requires disclosure and accountability.
Layal Behnam, programme director at the Maharat Foundation, which participated in drafting the law through parliamentary committees, explained the importance of this reform in comments to The New Arab.
"Media outlets are not ordinary commercial institutions. They help shape public opinion, and citizens therefore have the right to know the identity of the owner of the media outlet through which they obtain news and information. They also have the right to know who has the power to influence its editorial line," she said.
"This knowledge is particularly important in the Lebanese context, where media ownership intersects with political and economic interests," she added.
"Most media outlets are directly or indirectly linked to political figures or forces. The transparency stipulated by the law therefore allows citizens to read the news not only through its content but also by understanding the context and potential interests behind it," she further noted.
She explained that "pluralism is not simply about having a large number of media outlets but about ensuring genuine diversity in interests, ownership and voices".
Similarly, MP Halima Kaakour told The New Arab that "this provision lies at the heart of the principles of transparency, democracy and good governance in the media sector".
"There is no doubt that many media outlets have not welcomed it because it forces them to disclose their funding sources and, consequently, reveals their agendas in every television programme or political position. In other words, it shows why they attack one political side or another," she said.
However, media outlets did not publicly express their opposition to the provision, because, as Kaakour argued, "it is difficult for them to publicly reject transparency in ownership and funding sources".
"But they exploited our opposition to Articles 104 and 105, which criminalise the deliberate fabrication of misleading information and false news in vague terms, to raise their voices against those provisions. They did not do so to preserve the gains introduced by the law, as we did, but rather to prevent its passage and send it back for further study," she added.
This partly echoes Behnam's comments.
Kaakour further noted that "some media institutions managed to influence certain formulations during earlier stages of the law's review by parliamentary committees".
“This was evident in the provisions setting ownership limits. Some earlier drafts stipulated that a single person should not own more than 10% of a television or radio station. This became a clear subject of debate and objection until the provision was removed from the final version”, she said.
Ayman Mhanna, executive director of the Samir Kassir Foundation, distinguished transparency in media ownership and transparency in funding sources in comments to The New Arab.
Regarding ownership, he said, "Anyone can obtain a document from the commercial register showing the shareholders in media outlets under the Right to Information Law".
"The problem arises when investigating actual ownership. Examining the names of shareholders in media outlets shows that some work as employees in other companies owned by businessmen. This raises questions about whether they are merely nominal owners acting on behalf of actual owners who prefer not to disclose their identities," he pointed out.
On sources of funding, Mhanna said that "many media outlets say their funding comes from advertising, which is normal. But when the funding behind that advertising is linked to political and economic interests, we are looking at a different picture".
"For example, the Association of Banks in Lebanon announced that it had allocated a large sum to support Lebanese media in the coming period," he explained. "In theory, this is justifiable, since anyone with an interest seeks ways to make their voice heard through the media. But the question is whether advertising funding will affect the editorial line or be limited to placing advertisements for food, furniture, cars and other products."
"Will this funding, for example, be used to support particular candidates who align with the interests of the Association of Banks in the next elections?" he rhetorically asked, and then said, "the answers to these questions are not addressed in the new law. Instead, they require investigative journalism to highlight the extent to which advertising funding influences editorial lines".
In the same vein, Behnam believes that "knowing the identities of media owners is not enough; funders must also be disclosed. We believe that, in some cases, identifying the funder is more important than identifying the owner".
"Media institutions have substantial financial costs. If they do not have sufficient revenue, they will depend on loans, grants or ongoing funding from a political or economic entity," she explained.
"It is precisely at this point that a relationship of influence can emerge, even if the political or economic entity does not own shares in the media outlet," she added.
The reform introduced by Lebanon's new media law is a positive development, but in Lebanon, the real test always lies in implementation.
On this, MP Kaakour explained "the law provides mechanisms and means to compel media institutions to be transparent about their ownership and funding sources."
"Article 19 gives the National Media Authority the power to audit the information submitted by institutions and their owners, using all available means of verification, including appointing auditors to ensure the accuracy of their declarations," she added.
The matter does not end there. According to Kaakour, "Article 20 sets out penalties for violating transparency and disclosure obligations. It imposes a fine on the media institution or its owners for failing to meet disclosure requirements, in addition to requiring them to rectify the violation. In the event of repeated violations or delays in compliance, the fine is doubled".
"What we need is a genuine willingness on the part of the executive authorities to implement Lebanon's media law, as well as a genuine willingness on the part of media outlets to comply with its provisions rather than evade or circumvent them," she explained.
The New Arab is publishing this article as part of a joint fellowship programme between the Lebanese Journalists Syndicate and the Qraib programme, in support of and raising awareness about media law reforms.
Article translated from Arabic by Afrah Almatwari. To read the original, click here.