Hamas: No captives-for-prisoners swap deal with Israel unless Gaza war ends

Hamas' acting Gaza chief reiterated that the captives held in Gaza would not be released unless Israel ends the war on Gaza, and are open to truce talks.
3 min read
20 November, 2024
Khalil al-Hayya said the Israeli captives would not be released unless the war on Gaza ends [Getty]

Hamas' acting Gaza chief Khalil al-Hayya said in remarks broadcast on Wednesday that there would be no captives-for-prisoners swap deal with Israel unless the war on the Palestinian enclave ended.

"Without an end to the war, there can be no prisoner swap," Hayya said in a televised interview with the group's Al-Aqsa television channel, reiterating the group's position on how to bring the war to an end.

"If the aggression is not ended, why would the resistance and in particular Hamas, return the prisoners [captives]?" he said. "How would a sane or an insane person lose a strong card he owns while the war is continuing?"

Hayya, who led the group's negotiating team in talks with Qatari and Egyptian mediators, blamed the lack of progress on Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who in turn holds the group responsible for the stalled talks.

"There are contacts under way with some countries and mediators to revive this file [negotiation]. We are ready to continue with those efforts but it is more important to see a real will on the side of the occupation to end the aggression," said Hayya.

"The reality proves that Netanyahu is the one who undermines it [negotiations]," he added.

Speaking during a visit to Gaza on Tuesday, Netanyahu said that Hamas would not rule the Palestinian enclave after the war had ended and that Israel had destroyed the group's military capabilities.

Truce talks stalling

Netanyahu also said Israel had not given up trying to locate the 101 remaining captives believed to be still in the enclave, and he offered a $5 million reward for the return of each one.

Hamas wants a deal that ends the war and sees the release of Israeli and foreign captives held  in Gaza as well as Palestinians jailed by Israel, while Netanyahu vowed the war can only end once Hamas is eradicated.

Qatar, a key ceasefire mediator alongside Egypt, said it had informed Hamas and Israel that it would stall its mediation efforts unless the two warring parties showed "willingness and seriousness" to reach a deal.

On 19 November, Qatari foreign ministry spokesperson Majed Al-Ansari said the political office of Hamas in Doha had not been permanently closed.

Earlier this month Reuters quoted a U.S. official saying Washington had asked Qatar to expel the group and that Doha had passed this message on to Hamas.

Al-Ansari said the Hamas office had been created to facilitate mediation efforts to end the Gaza war.

Hayya said Hamas had welcomed an Egyptian proposal for Hamas to form an administrative committee with the rival Fatah movement of President Mahmoud Abbas to run the Gaza Strip, a move that addresses the outstanding question of how the enclave would be run when the fighting stops.

But an agreement has yet to be finalised, Hayya said. Israel rejects any Hamas role in governing Gaza after the war and neither does it trust Abbas' Palestinian Authority to take over running the enclave.

Israel war on Gaza has killed nearly 44,000 Palestinians and wounded over 103,898 others since 7 October 2023, according to the Gaza health ministry. It has also plunged the Strip into a deep humanitarian crisis and left millions in  desperate for food, fuel, water, and sanitation.