Flydubai incident fuels political row over Israeli security failures

Flydubai incident exposes major Israeli security failures, fuelling a political blame game as Netanyahu faces accusations of exploiting the crisis.
Haifa
05 October, 2026
Last Update
05 October, 2026 13:58 PM
The Flydubai incident has sparked a security and political row in Israel, with questions mounting over aviation safeguards and responsibility for the failures. [Getty]

A major security and political row has erupted in Israel over the flydubai incident, as questions mount over how an Omani co-pilot accused of plotting to crash the passenger jet was repeatedly allowed to fly into the country despite reported warnings over weaknesses in the screening of foreign air crews.

The controversy has widened beyond Israel's security agencies and transport ministry, with opposition politicians accusing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government of presiding over another serious security failure and then seeking to turn the narrowly avoided disaster into political capital.

Hamam al-Hammami, the Omani co-pilot accused of attacking the Indian captain of flydubai flight FZ1073 on 30 September, allegedly told investigators that he had planned to crash the aircraft into Israel's Ben Gurion Airport, according to Israeli reports.

Other accounts, however, have offered different versions of his alleged plans. Israeli news site Ynet reported that Hammami intended to target a US military base in Jordan if he was unable to reach Ben Gurion Airport.

The investigation remains ongoing and the precise motive and intended target have not been independently established.

A picture emerging from reports over the weekend portrayed Hammami as a possible lone actor who had allegedly spent months planning an attack, with no evidence so far publicly establishing that he acted on behalf of an armed organisation or foreign government.

Some Israeli reports claimed Hammami had considered carrying out an attack on previous flights and used earlier journeys to Tel Aviv to gather information. One report alleged that he had considered crashing an aircraft during a flight to Israel in July but abandoned the plan because of his friendship with a crew member.

Live Story

Warnings over security gaps

The incident has instead intensified scrutiny of apparent gaps in Israel's own aviation security arrangements.

Haaretz reported that Israel's Shin Bet domestic security agency had repeatedly warned the transport ministry in recent years about weaknesses in the monitoring of foreign flight crews and passengers.

Sources involved in securing flights to Israel told the newspaper that Shin Bet had previously recommended transferring responsibility for screening foreign airlines and their passengers to Israel's civil aviation authorities.

Israel's National Security Council reportedly made a similar recommendation last year, but the transport ministry opposed the move and retained control over screening and oversight.

A 2024 Israeli state comptroller report examining the years 2022 and 2023 had also identified serious shortcomings in aviation security, including arrangements covering aircraft operated by foreign airlines.

Although the transport ministry formally bears responsibility, according to Israeli media reports, both Shin Bet and Mossad were aware of difficulties facing the ministry's security division but did not intervene.

Yedioth Ahronoth reported that the incident had exposed a fundamental question for which Israeli authorities still appeared to have no clear answer on who was actually responsible for protecting passengers on foreign flights bound for Israel.

Haaretz also reported that none of the transport ministry, Shin Bet or Mossad had taken responsibility for failing to examine information previously supplied about the Omani co-pilot, despite all three having legal access to databases containing information supplied by airlines.

Netanyahu's office said on Sunday, four days after the incident, that the prime minister had instructed National Security Council chief Shmuel Ben Ezra to appoint an official to conduct a comprehensive review of security arrangements for foreign civilian aviation travelling to Israel.

The announcement came despite the National Security Council having already examined the issue last year.

Live Story

Netanyahu exploiting incident ahead of elections

The security controversy has also developed into a bitter political dispute after Netanyahu sought to highlight the actions of Israeli passengers who intervened after the Indian captain managed to open the cockpit door.

Netanyahu met passengers involved in the incident and released footage of the encounter, while presenting the episode as an example of "Israeli heroism" and suggesting that warnings he had issued shortly before the incident demonstrated his awareness of looming security threats.

His opponents accused him of attempting to claim political credit for the prevention of a disaster that they said exposed failures under his own government.

Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the Yashar party, said Netanyahu's government had "learned nothing from October 7", arguing that Transport Minister Miri Regev should resign or be dismissed.

Yair Golan, leader of the Democrats, described the incident as evidence of what he called the government's broader failures and accused Netanyahu and his ministers of sacrificing public safety for political interests.

Former prime minister Naftali Bennett was similarly scathing.

"Instead of investigating and drawing lessons to prevent the next disaster, Netanyahu and Miri Regev are celebrating the failure that happened on their watch," Bennett remarked.

He drew a direct comparison with the failures surrounding the 7 October 2023 Hamas-led attacks, accusing Netanyahu and his ministers of complacency and neglecting security.

Avigdor Lieberman, leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, placed responsibility on Shin Bet and called for its chief, David Zini, to resign.

"The culture Netanyahu has created, according to which no one is responsible for failures while successes always have one father named Bibi, must stop," Lieberman said.

Israeli commentators draw October 7 parallels

The criticism has extended into the Israeli press, where several prominent commentators have compared the failures exposed by the flydubai incident with those preceding the 7 October attacks.

Writing in Haaretz, military analyst Amos Harel said Netanyahu had quickly embraced the "heroes" of the incident and attempted to associate himself with the successful prevention of the alleged attack.

Netanyahu and sympathetic Israeli media outlets have pointed to remarks he made at Tel Nof airbase the previous day, when he warned of attempts by Israel's enemies to disrupt the country's elections.

Harel, however, wrote that subsequent checks with security agencies showed there had been no specific intelligence warning concerning such a plot.

Instead, he said, officials had been assessing a combination of broader risks, including the election period, Jewish holidays, the anniversary of the 7 October attacks and increased general warnings about possible attacks on Israelis abroad.

Harel argued that the incident required a comprehensive investigation, accountability for the security failures and immediate action to close existing gaps.

Yedioth Ahronoth columnist Nahum Barnea also compared the episode with 7 October, pointing to what he described as the same pattern of institutional negligence before a crisis, civilians acting decisively when disaster struck, and political leaders subsequently avoiding responsibility.

"The similarity between the two disasters, the one that happened and the one that was prevented, sends chills down the spine," Barnea wrote.