Breadcrumb
Egypt, Saint Catherine's Monastery move to resolve months-long status dispute
A legal dispute between the Egyptian government and Saint Catherine's Monastery is drawing to a close after the two sides agreed on the terms of a possible settlement.
News of the settlement emerged on 24 October, when Archbishop Symeon of Saint Catherine's Monastery sent a letter to the Egyptian Foreign Ministry, expressing his intention to sign the settlement agreement.
The expected settlement would end months of uncertainty over the monastery's legal status and a potential strain in relations between Egypt and Greece, with the religious assets of the monastery, its administration and heritage being globally famed as belonging to the Greek Orthodox monastic tradition.
Greek Foreign Minister George Gerapetritis described the breakthrough as a "historic day" for Hellenism and Orthodoxy, in general.
"The beacon of Orthodoxy, the Holy Monastery of Saint Catherine of Mount Sinai, is acquiring a solid legal foundation through the agreement between the Monastery and the Egyptian State," the Greek minister said in a statement on October 24.
He also described the agreement as the "embodiment of a profound strategic relationship" with Egypt, referring to the expansion of this relationship across all fields.
Inside the draft settlement
The Egyptian Foreign Ministry has welcomed approval by Archbishop Symeon to sign a contract to end the legal dispute.
Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty reaffirmed Egypt's centuries-old commitment to safeguarding the monastery and ensuring that its spiritual and religious standing remains intact, according to a statement by the Egyptian Foreign Ministry on October 24.
While full details of the agreement have not been officially released, statements by Archbishop Symeon and reports in the Greek press indicate that the deal strikes a balance between Egyptian sovereign law and the monastery's historical autonomy.
Egypt is expected to recognise the monastery's right to govern its internal affairs, including the admission of monks and the election of its archbishop and its administration.
The monastery, its churches, chapels and pilgrimage sites would remain dedicated to Orthodox Christian worship, with only the monastery's monks entitled to possess and use them freely and in perpetuity, according to reports in the Greek press.
The monastery would, meanwhile, commit to retaining the site's designated religious use and be required to obtain permits from Egyptian archaeological authorities for work on its premises.
The monastery could also seek leases for agricultural land that an Egyptian appeals court had previously ruled belonged to the Egyptian state.
The proposed agreement would also require Egypt to protect the monks' way of life, amid concerns that increased tourism could disrupt the monastery's daily routine.
The possible agreement, Egyptian observers said, is a win-win for Egypt and the monastery.
Mustafa Waziri, former head of the Supreme Council of Antiquities, the executive arm of the Egyptian Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities, said the proposed settlement serves the interests of the monastery as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
"It also serves the interests of the monks of the monastery," he told The New Arab.
Waziri added that the proposed settlement protects Egyptian state properties, while preserving the spiritual and historical status of the monastery.
"Settling the dispute in such a peaceful manner nips tensions between Cairo and Athens in the bud," Waziri said.
Legal ambiguity
Founded in the 6th century, Saint Catherine's Monastery is the oldest Christian house of worship still in use for its initial function.
Standing at the foot of Mount Horeb where the Old Testament records Moses receiving the Tablets of the Law, the monastery's walls and buildings are of great significance to studies of Byzantine architecture. It houses outstanding collections of early Christian manuscripts and icons.
The legal status of the monastery remained uncertain for a millennium and a half. In recent years, however, disputes with the Egyptian government over this status seeped into local courtrooms.
In 2015, South Sinai authorities launched legal proceedings, disputing the monastery's ownership and use of dozens of plots of land around the monastery.
In 2024, South Sinai authorities and the archbishop of the monastery agreed on a draft settlement, but this settlement has yet to be formally signed, according to Greek media.
In 2025, the Ismailia Appeals Court upheld state ownership of the plots of land referred to above, while recognizing the right of the monastery's monks to use the site and its religious and archaeological areas.
This legal stalemate eventually drew high-level involvement from Egypt and Greece, becoming a central topic of discussions between the Egyptian president and the Greek prime minister and the foreign ministers of the two countries.
Diplomatic stakes
No specific date has been set for signing the deal between the Egyptian government and Archbishop Symeon.
Nonetheless, the archbishop, who was elected as the monastery's abbot almost a year ago, is expected to sign such a deal once he recovers from his illness and resumes his duties.
The deal reportedly enjoys explicit support from the Ecumenical Patriarchates of Constantinople, Jerusalem and Alexandria, as well as the Orthodox Churches of Greece and Cyprus.
In a statement, Archbishop Symeon said this backing gave him and the Sinai Brotherhood the support needed to proceed with the signing in the near future.
The breakthrough comes at a critical moment for relations between Egypt and Greece, as both Eastern Mediterranean nations join forces against the latest ratification of a controversial maritime boundary delimitation deal between Turkey and Libya by the eastern Libya parliament, specialists in Cairo said.
The deal, initially signed by the western Libya government and Ankara in 2019, is viewed by Cairo and Athens as violating their Eastern Mediterranean rights and encroaching on their territories.
The two capitals have already protested the latest move by the eastern Libya parliament, which was a major focus of discussions between the Egyptian and Turkish foreign ministers in Ankara earlier in October.
Some Greeks accuse their government of giving up rights to Saint Catherine's Monastery to secure continued Egyptian presence in the Greek camp in the showdown with Turkey over Eastern Mediterranean rights.
In Egypt, the potential deal is seen as an important move for clearing the air between Cairo and Athens at an important time for their relations.
Ambassador Rakha Ahmed, a former assistant to the Egyptian foreign minister, said Egypt and Greece agree on several key portfolios.
"Cooperation on these portfolios, I believe, shouldn't encounter political roadblocks," Ambassador Ahmed told TNA.
"The legal dispute over the status of the monastery could have strained ties between the two countries, but Egypt has succeeded in containing the issue quickly," he added.