The Green Party’s decision to adopt a motion classifying Zionism as a form of racism has caused uproar in the UK. The motion calls Zionism an ideology which supports an “ethnonationalist Jewish state” and calls for a “single democratic state in all of historic Palestine”.
The Green Party’s leader, Zack Polanski, did not vote on the motion, but found himself banned from Israel as a result.
Rabbi Charley Baginsky of the Movement for Progressive Judaism described the motion as “incredibly sinister” and told LBC she was “really distressed” at the vote, saying that Zionism was a key part of many Jewish people’s identity.
The Board of Deputies of British Jews said that the move would stoke “anti-Jewish hatred”, citing attacks on Jews in the UK in the past year.
The resolution was even opposed by leading members of the Green Party itself.
Caroline Lucas, the party’s former leader and its first-ever MP, said, “I view the Israeli government as racist, I believe its actions in Gaza amount to genocide, and I support the BDS campaign. And yet I remain firmly opposed to this resolution.”
She justified this by claiming that Zionism was historically a response to the racist persecution of Jews in Europe.
Media coverage in the UK has been extremely critical, with The Economist calling the motion “shameful” and the Daily Mail suggesting that the Greens were now the UK’s “first openly anti-Semitic party”.
It is often forgotten, however, that the UN itself once classified Zionism as racism.
UN condemnation of Zionism
While the UN was instrumental in the creation of Israel, with the majority of its members voting in favour of the 1947 Partition of Palestine, by 1975, African and Asian states had gained independence from European colonial rule and formed a large proportion of the world body’s membership. Most of these voted for UN General Assembly Resolution 3379, which determined that Zionism was “a form of racism and racial discrimination”, alongside the Arab League countries which sponsored and proposed it.
The Soviet Union, which was one of the first countries in the world to recognise Israel, had by that time become an ally of Arab countries and, along with its East European allies, also voted in favour. The resolution passed with 72 votes for and 35 against, with the US and its Western European allies voting against.
The vote took place at a time when Israel’s 1967 occupation of the West Bank and Gaza was relatively new. Israel subjected the Palestinian population of those territories to military rule while denying them citizenship. It also began establishing settlements in the territories in violation of international law.
Memories of the 1948 Nakba, in which Zionist forces expelled the vast majority of the Palestinian population, were also much fresher than they are today.
South Africa and Israel
Israel at the time was also a close ally of apartheid South Africa, with the two countries cooperating in defence, intelligence, and the development of nuclear weapons, with both viewing themselves as outposts of “civilisation” in a hostile environment.
As a South African government publication put it at the time, “Israel and South Africa have one thing above all else in common: they are both situated in a predominantly hostile world inhabited by dark peoples."
It was very easy to draw parallels between the two countries and the statements of Israeli leaders themselves appeared to confirm them. As Yitzhak Navon, Israel’s president between 1978 and 1983, said, “The very point of [the Israeli] Labor [party’s] Zionist programme is to have as much land as possible and as few Arabs as possible!”
These parallels helped explain the overwhelming African and Asian support for the UNGA resolution.
Israel, however, bitterly rejected the resolution, with its ambassador, Chaim Herzog (father of Israel’s current president), claiming that some of Israel’s Palestinian citizens – within the 1948 boundaries – had gained high-ranking positions within its government and military.
US ambassador to the UN Daniel Patrick Moynihan told the UN that it was “about to make anti-Semitism international law."
Repealing the resolution for ‘peace’
By 1991, the global environment had changed. The collapse of the Soviet Union had deprived Arab countries of a key strategic ally and supplier of weapons and changed the balance of power across the world. The Iraqi invasion of Kuwait and the subsequent Gulf War had left the US in a much stronger position in the Middle East.
Israel demanded that the UN repeal Resolution 3379 as a precondition for its participation in the 1991 Madrid peace conference, which eventually led to the 1993 Oslo Accords between the PLO and Israel.
The UN General Assembly duly repealed the resolution under US pressure, with even some Arab countries – such as Egypt, Morocco, and Oman – staying away rather than voting against.
However, all of the original factors behind the 1975 resolution remained. The Oslo Peace Process ended up entrenching Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank, its settlement policies, and its encirclement and siege of Palestinian communities – notably Gaza.
The number of Israeli settlers in the West Bank has gone up from just a few thousand in 1975 to around 700,000 today.
Human rights groups such as Amnesty International have concluded that Israel is committing “the crime of apartheid” both within its 1948 boundaries and in the West Bank and Gaza, long after apartheid as a ruling system ended in South Africa.
Israeli leaders are engaging in much more bloodthirsty rhetoric than Navon’s “as few Arabs as possible” remarks, with far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir recently calling for “30-40” Palestinians to be killed every day.
What may have changed, however, is the increasing censorship regarding discourse on Israel and the growing and deliberate conflation of criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism.
Singers who chant “Free Palestine” at music concerts are attacked on the grounds that they make Jews feel unsafe, while artwork by Palestinian children displayed at a UK hospital is removed for the same reason.
By passing a motion equating Zionism with racism, the Green Party only stated a position once held by a significant section of global opinion. However, it did so at a time when Israel is far more aggressive in pushing its narrative than it was 50 years ago.